Most 'classical' music performed today in churches and concert halls all over the world, and recorded on disc, belongs among the category of what is called 'art music'. It was written by composers and has come down to us in fixed form, either in manuscript or in printed editions. However, in the course of history, much music - and probably even most - was sung and played by people who did not use any written notes; many of them were probably not even able to read music. Improvisation was the name of the game, and music was handed over from one generation to another orally. It had no fixed form, and in the course of time, both texts and music often changed considerably. In most cases their original forms are not known, unless at some time such music was written down. That is the case with the music which is the subject of a recording by an the Makaris [1], whose name is derived from makar (pl. makaris), a royal court troubadour of medieval Scotland; the term was resurrected centuries later and is used now to describe a Scottish bard or poet (booklet).
The title of this disc also needs some explanation. David Rizzio, of Italian origin, was secretary to Mary, Queen of Scots. In 1566 he was murdered by Mary's Protestant opponents. He was also a bass singer, but there is no reason to think that he has ever written any note of music. However, a number of songs are attributed to him, and that was the work of William Thomson (c1684-c1762), who in 1726 published a collection of songs under the title of Orpheus Caledonius. It was the first printed edition of arrangements of traditional Scottish songs, consisting fifty settings by Thomson over a figured bass. For 43 melodies no composer was mentioned, and it is likely that Thomson plagiarized their texts from a book of Scottish poetry published two years before. Thomson attributed the seven remaining melodies to David Rizzio. The reason for that may well have been that the Italian style was fashionable and that attributing melodies to an Italian Thomson hoped to sell more copies. Several respected composers fell for this myth, including James Oswald and Francesco Geminiani.
Makaris's disc presents all 22 songs falsely attributed to Rizzio, in various arrangements, mostly by composers from the 18th century (Geminiani, Veracini, JC Bach), but also by members of the ensemble. Most of them are performed in a combination of voice and instruments, and some are performed in instrumental versions. In some cases, arrangements by different composers have been mixed. The only composer who is represented with original music, is James Oswald. This disc seems to me of great interest to any lover of traditional music. What we have here is the performance in historical fashion - with instruments of the 18th century - of music from a stage in its development in which it was fixed. It is not only an interesting contribution to our knowledge of the music scene in 18th-century England, but also the history of traditional music and the way it developed in the course of time. Even if you don't understand all the texts, this is an enjoyable disc, as the members of the ensemble perform these pieces with audible enthusiasm and technical skills on their respective instruments.
The second disc is more modest with regard to the participation of instruments. Most pieces are played on the harp, either solo or with violin; the latter was the instrument of the Irish Turlough O'Carolan, and he is one of the best-represented composers on the programme recorded by the ensemble Spirit & Pleasure [2]. This ensemble consists of Christoph Mayer (violin) and Johanna Seitz (harp), in a few pieces joined by Monika Nielen on the oboe. Whereas Makaris entirely focused on tunes from Scotland, here we also get some from Ireland and England. The above-mentioned Geminiani is also represented, and so is James Oswald, who was from Scotland and was educated on the cello. He settled in London and became acquainted with the English, Italian and French styles. He a had a strong influence on later generations of composers.
The pieces in the programme belong among two categories. On the one hand we have 'authentic' arrangements of traditional tunes in baroque style by the likes of Geminiani, O'Carolan and Oswald. On the other hand we have traditional tunes arranged in a comparable way by the performers themselves. The fact that composers of the 18th century arranged these tunes - and they were followed by classical masters such as Haydn and Beethoven - justifies this procedure, and it seems to me that they have done a fine job. The traditional tunes have their own charm, and even those who have no great interest in traditional music as such may well enjoy these tunes in a baroque shape. In this case there are no texts which are hard to understand, as the songs are performed instrumentally, which again is an entirely legitimate procedure.
[1] "The Galant David Rizzio - Eighteenth-century arrangements of traditional Scottish songs"
Makaris
Olde Focus Recordings FCR921 (© 2022) details
[2] "Good taste - Baroque folk from Ireland, Scotland and England"
Spirit & Pleasure
Aeolus AE-10346 (© 2021) details
Saturday, September 2, 2023
Friday, August 4, 2023
Viola da gamba solo
In the 16th and 17th centuries, the viola da gamba was one of the most revered instruments. It was played in consort, but music for viola da gamba solo was also written, and especially music to be played the lyra way, as it was called, was very popular. Although the term lyra viol referred to the way of playing in the first place, the lyra viol was different from other viols in that it had six gut strings. Music for lyra viol always indicates the tuning in which it has to be played. More than fifty tunings are documented; Alfonso Ferrabosco [1], one of the main composers for the lyra viol, confines himself to three. The pieces in his collection Lessons for 1. 2. and 3 viols of 1609 are ordered according to tuning. Most are printed in pairs on the same page, and Richard Boothby, in his selection from the collection, performs them as such. Most pairs consist of alman and coranto, but there are also pairs of galliard and coranto and pavan (pavin) and coranto. In addition, the collection includes three preludes and a single pavan. Boothby also selected two pairs for two viols, in which he is seconded by Asako Morikawa. Recently Ferrabosco's oeuvre has received quite some interest; I reviewed two recordings of consort music and music for lyra viol. Boothby's recording is a most welcome addition to the discography, also because of his engaging and dynamic playing. This disc is pretty much an ideal way to get to know the lyra viol and its music as well as the oeuvre of Ferrabosco.
Matteo Cicchitti [2] recorded a programme of music by four composers, two of which are very well-known (Diego Ortiz, Tobias Hume), whereas the two others are largely unknown quantities. The programme starts with four recercadas from the Tratado de glosas by Ortiz. Cicchitti then goes on with six pieces by Hume, taken from the first book which was printed in 1605. These are pieces that undoubtedly find their origin in improvisations by the composer. Then we get some pieces by Benjamin Hely (fl 1680-1690), who in 1699 published The Compleat Violist, which was intended as instruction material for 'young practitioners'. These pieces are recorded here for the first time. The same goes for the largest part of this disc: 21 ricercares by the Italian composer Angelo Michele Bertalotti (c1665-1747). Given that the viola da gamba was hardly played in Italy after the mid-17th century, one may wonder about the reasons these pieces were written. It needs to be said that they are not intended for the viola da gamba. They are taken from Bertalotti's Regole facilissime per apprendere con facilità, e prestezza li canti fermo e figurato dati alle stampe per comodo delli putti delle Scuole Pie di Bologna of 1698. This collection consists of pieces for one and for two voices, intended for vocal training. One could compare them with solfeggi. They have been transposed down to fit the viola da gamba. As there is little chance that such pieces will ever be recorded in vocal performances (for which they are not intended anyway), this disc offers an opportunity to get to know them. Fortunately, they can stand on their own feet this way, especially if they are played as well as by Matteo Cicchitti, who has presented here an interesting survey of what was written for the viol or can be played on it. I was especially struck by Hely's music, and I hope that more of his (small) oeuvre is going to be recorded. It seems well worth it.
Roberto Gini [3], in the liner-notes to his recording, sheds light on the conflict between two ways of playing the viola da gamba and composing of music for it which took place in France in the second half of the 17th century. On the one hand there was the jeu d'harmonie, which was connected to the old way of playing, the ancient port de main, and which combined melody and accompaniment, which suggests polyphony. The nouveau port de main represented the domination of melody, the jeu de mélodie, in which the viol played mostly just one melodic line (without avoiding harmonies altogether). This style was promoted by Sieur de Sainte-Colombe and his followers, among whom Marin Marais was the most prominent. It does not surprise that the latter started to write music for the viol with basso continuo, which provided the counterpoint that earlier was taken care of by the viol itself. Gini has recorded a programme of pieces in the 'old manner', by composers from France, England and Germany. The origin of chordal playing was England, and it is represented here by William Young, who emigrated to the continent and worked for a number of years in Austria. Nicolas Hotman and Monsieur Du Buisson are the earliest representatives of the French viol school. Theodore Steffkin(s) was of German birth, worked for some time in England and also in Italy, which makes him an interesting link between the English viol school and viol playing at the continent. Gini has produced a historically interesting and musically compelling recording of music that is seldom performed and recorded. He plays the selected pieces brilliantly, and his liner-notes are of great informative value. This is a disc no lover of the viola da gamba should miss.
Sieur de Machy (fl 2nd half of the 17th C) [4] was a composer who got directly involved in the debate between the 'harmonic' and 'melodic' schools. We know about this from the treatise Traité de la Viole by Jean Rousseau (1687), who was a representative of the 'melodic' school. Unfortunately Machy's contribution to the debate has been lost. We only know his views through liberal quotations in Rousseau's book - of which we can't be sure that they are correct - and the composer's preface to his book of suites. In his music melodic and harmonic episodes alternate. Machy wanted to underline the autonomy of the viol. He specifically composed suites which could be played by the viol without any accompaniment as was becoming increasingly the standard in the last decades of the 17th century. It is exactly for that reason that he emphasized the 'harmonic' nature of the viol, and stressed the importance of tenües (held notes) - notes that must be held even when they are no longer physically played by the bow. These are sounds whose resonance must be cultivated and prolonged so as to create harmony with the sounds successively produced by the bow. This reflects the ideal of a 'self-sufficient' instrument. Another feature of Machy's suites is that he explores the entire range of the viola da gamba. The Australian gambist Shaun Ng presents four suites in D minor and major and in G minor and major respectively. They open with a prélude, which has a marked improvisatory character, and continue with a sequence of dances, some of which are followed by a double. The disc ends appropriately with a chaconne. Ng is an outstanding player and performs these suites brilliantly. I noted pretty strong dynamic differences, about which I am a little in two minds, as I wonder whether this was part of the French style of playing. I don't know the answer. Anyway, given that Machy's music is not that well-known and its quality is without any doubt, this engaging interpretation of these four suites is most welcome.
Johanna Rose [5] makes an interesting connection between French music for the viola da gamba and what was written in Germany. However, as she focuses on music for the viola da gamba without basso continuo, and plays music by Monsieur de Sainte-Colombe (c1640-c1700), one might expect her to turn to contemporaries of his in Germany, or to Georg Philipp Telemann, who also composed music for viola da gamba solo, which was clearly inspired by the French style he so admired. In fact, Ms Rose turns to Bach: he wrote three sonatas for viola da gamba and obbligato harpsichord, but no music for the viola da gamba alone. She plays two of Bach's cello suites on a viola da gamba with seven strings, an instrument she herself designed. Interestingly, it is Sainte-Colombe who is credited with having added a seventh string to the viola da gamba. In the liner-notes, it is argued that Bach's cello suites are rooted in the past, and that they are a blending of old and new. Sainte-Colombe was a representative of the 'melodic' school, although in fact he mixes melodic and harmonic elements. That is also the case with Bach's cello suites. From that perspective the connection makes sense. Johanna Rose plays the last two of Bach's cello suites and excerpts from a suite by Sainte-Colombe, embraced by pieces from the pen of his son, who lived and worked in England. Interestingly, the latter's prélude with which this part of the disc opens, is largely written in the 'harmonic' style. Sainte-Colombe is better-known for his Concerts à deux violes esgales than for his solo suites. That makes this disc a valuable addition to the discography anyway, and that also concerns the pieces by his son. Ms Rose is a fine player who does deliver excellent performances of Sainte-Colombe. Her Bach is also nice to hear; here there is more competition, and it is certainly interesting to hear the cello suites on the viola da gamba. They fare pretty well, although I prefer to hear them on a cello.
The Fantasias by Georg Philipp Telemann [6], which one may have expected from Johanna Rose, come from Israel Castillo Hernández. Since they were rediscovered about ten years ago, quite a number of recordings have been released. It is easy to understand why they have become so popular among performers. Today Telemann is generally ackowledged as one of the great composers of his time. The qualities of his fantasias for the transverse flute are well-known, and obviously that made gambists curious about the fantasias for their instrument. For a long time they were assumed to be lost, and when they were rediscovered, they turned out to be of the same high quality as the flute fantasias. Telemann himself was certainly not a viol virtuoso, but he was able to play almost any instrument in vogue in his time. He knew enough about the technicalities of each instrument to write idiomatic music for it. The viola da gamba plays a substantial role in his oeuvre, which does not surprise, considering his liking of the French style. The fantasias were written in the time that the galant idiom had become fashionable, but they include quite some counterpoint, for instance in a number of fugues. Like Bach and Sainte-Colombe, they are a mixture of melodic and harmonic passages. One can leave it to Telemann to create quite some variety within this set of twelve fantasias. These come off very well in this fine recording by Castillo Hernández, who is not afraid to emphasize the dramatic features of some pieces, such as the opening movement of the Fantasia No. 11. This is a compelling recording, which can compete with any recording that has been released previously.
[1] Alfonso Ferrabosco II: "Music to hear - Music for lyra viol from 1609"
Richard Boothby, Asaka Morikawa, viola da gamba
Signum Classics SIGCD757 (© 2023) details
[2] "Ricercare e Canzoni" (Ortiz, Hume, Hely, Bertalotti)
Matteo Cicchitti, viola da gamba
Challenge Classics CC72918 (© 2022) details
[3] "Viola da gamba - Le Jeu d'Harmonie"
Roberto Gini, viola da gamba
Aulicus Classics ALC 0047 (© 2021) details
[4] Mr. De Machy: "Pieces de Violle"
Shaun Ng, viola da gamba
A415 Music CD006 (© 2022) details
[5] "7 Movements - J.S. Bach, Sainte-Colombe father & son"
Johanna Rose, viola da gamba
Rubicon RCD1101 (© 2022) details
[6] Georg Philipp Telemann: 12 Fantaisies pour la basse de violle
Israel Castillo Hernández, viola da gamba
Urtext JBCC334 (© 2022) details
Matteo Cicchitti [2] recorded a programme of music by four composers, two of which are very well-known (Diego Ortiz, Tobias Hume), whereas the two others are largely unknown quantities. The programme starts with four recercadas from the Tratado de glosas by Ortiz. Cicchitti then goes on with six pieces by Hume, taken from the first book which was printed in 1605. These are pieces that undoubtedly find their origin in improvisations by the composer. Then we get some pieces by Benjamin Hely (fl 1680-1690), who in 1699 published The Compleat Violist, which was intended as instruction material for 'young practitioners'. These pieces are recorded here for the first time. The same goes for the largest part of this disc: 21 ricercares by the Italian composer Angelo Michele Bertalotti (c1665-1747). Given that the viola da gamba was hardly played in Italy after the mid-17th century, one may wonder about the reasons these pieces were written. It needs to be said that they are not intended for the viola da gamba. They are taken from Bertalotti's Regole facilissime per apprendere con facilità, e prestezza li canti fermo e figurato dati alle stampe per comodo delli putti delle Scuole Pie di Bologna of 1698. This collection consists of pieces for one and for two voices, intended for vocal training. One could compare them with solfeggi. They have been transposed down to fit the viola da gamba. As there is little chance that such pieces will ever be recorded in vocal performances (for which they are not intended anyway), this disc offers an opportunity to get to know them. Fortunately, they can stand on their own feet this way, especially if they are played as well as by Matteo Cicchitti, who has presented here an interesting survey of what was written for the viol or can be played on it. I was especially struck by Hely's music, and I hope that more of his (small) oeuvre is going to be recorded. It seems well worth it.
Roberto Gini [3], in the liner-notes to his recording, sheds light on the conflict between two ways of playing the viola da gamba and composing of music for it which took place in France in the second half of the 17th century. On the one hand there was the jeu d'harmonie, which was connected to the old way of playing, the ancient port de main, and which combined melody and accompaniment, which suggests polyphony. The nouveau port de main represented the domination of melody, the jeu de mélodie, in which the viol played mostly just one melodic line (without avoiding harmonies altogether). This style was promoted by Sieur de Sainte-Colombe and his followers, among whom Marin Marais was the most prominent. It does not surprise that the latter started to write music for the viol with basso continuo, which provided the counterpoint that earlier was taken care of by the viol itself. Gini has recorded a programme of pieces in the 'old manner', by composers from France, England and Germany. The origin of chordal playing was England, and it is represented here by William Young, who emigrated to the continent and worked for a number of years in Austria. Nicolas Hotman and Monsieur Du Buisson are the earliest representatives of the French viol school. Theodore Steffkin(s) was of German birth, worked for some time in England and also in Italy, which makes him an interesting link between the English viol school and viol playing at the continent. Gini has produced a historically interesting and musically compelling recording of music that is seldom performed and recorded. He plays the selected pieces brilliantly, and his liner-notes are of great informative value. This is a disc no lover of the viola da gamba should miss.
Sieur de Machy (fl 2nd half of the 17th C) [4] was a composer who got directly involved in the debate between the 'harmonic' and 'melodic' schools. We know about this from the treatise Traité de la Viole by Jean Rousseau (1687), who was a representative of the 'melodic' school. Unfortunately Machy's contribution to the debate has been lost. We only know his views through liberal quotations in Rousseau's book - of which we can't be sure that they are correct - and the composer's preface to his book of suites. In his music melodic and harmonic episodes alternate. Machy wanted to underline the autonomy of the viol. He specifically composed suites which could be played by the viol without any accompaniment as was becoming increasingly the standard in the last decades of the 17th century. It is exactly for that reason that he emphasized the 'harmonic' nature of the viol, and stressed the importance of tenües (held notes) - notes that must be held even when they are no longer physically played by the bow. These are sounds whose resonance must be cultivated and prolonged so as to create harmony with the sounds successively produced by the bow. This reflects the ideal of a 'self-sufficient' instrument. Another feature of Machy's suites is that he explores the entire range of the viola da gamba. The Australian gambist Shaun Ng presents four suites in D minor and major and in G minor and major respectively. They open with a prélude, which has a marked improvisatory character, and continue with a sequence of dances, some of which are followed by a double. The disc ends appropriately with a chaconne. Ng is an outstanding player and performs these suites brilliantly. I noted pretty strong dynamic differences, about which I am a little in two minds, as I wonder whether this was part of the French style of playing. I don't know the answer. Anyway, given that Machy's music is not that well-known and its quality is without any doubt, this engaging interpretation of these four suites is most welcome.
Johanna Rose [5] makes an interesting connection between French music for the viola da gamba and what was written in Germany. However, as she focuses on music for the viola da gamba without basso continuo, and plays music by Monsieur de Sainte-Colombe (c1640-c1700), one might expect her to turn to contemporaries of his in Germany, or to Georg Philipp Telemann, who also composed music for viola da gamba solo, which was clearly inspired by the French style he so admired. In fact, Ms Rose turns to Bach: he wrote three sonatas for viola da gamba and obbligato harpsichord, but no music for the viola da gamba alone. She plays two of Bach's cello suites on a viola da gamba with seven strings, an instrument she herself designed. Interestingly, it is Sainte-Colombe who is credited with having added a seventh string to the viola da gamba. In the liner-notes, it is argued that Bach's cello suites are rooted in the past, and that they are a blending of old and new. Sainte-Colombe was a representative of the 'melodic' school, although in fact he mixes melodic and harmonic elements. That is also the case with Bach's cello suites. From that perspective the connection makes sense. Johanna Rose plays the last two of Bach's cello suites and excerpts from a suite by Sainte-Colombe, embraced by pieces from the pen of his son, who lived and worked in England. Interestingly, the latter's prélude with which this part of the disc opens, is largely written in the 'harmonic' style. Sainte-Colombe is better-known for his Concerts à deux violes esgales than for his solo suites. That makes this disc a valuable addition to the discography anyway, and that also concerns the pieces by his son. Ms Rose is a fine player who does deliver excellent performances of Sainte-Colombe. Her Bach is also nice to hear; here there is more competition, and it is certainly interesting to hear the cello suites on the viola da gamba. They fare pretty well, although I prefer to hear them on a cello.
The Fantasias by Georg Philipp Telemann [6], which one may have expected from Johanna Rose, come from Israel Castillo Hernández. Since they were rediscovered about ten years ago, quite a number of recordings have been released. It is easy to understand why they have become so popular among performers. Today Telemann is generally ackowledged as one of the great composers of his time. The qualities of his fantasias for the transverse flute are well-known, and obviously that made gambists curious about the fantasias for their instrument. For a long time they were assumed to be lost, and when they were rediscovered, they turned out to be of the same high quality as the flute fantasias. Telemann himself was certainly not a viol virtuoso, but he was able to play almost any instrument in vogue in his time. He knew enough about the technicalities of each instrument to write idiomatic music for it. The viola da gamba plays a substantial role in his oeuvre, which does not surprise, considering his liking of the French style. The fantasias were written in the time that the galant idiom had become fashionable, but they include quite some counterpoint, for instance in a number of fugues. Like Bach and Sainte-Colombe, they are a mixture of melodic and harmonic passages. One can leave it to Telemann to create quite some variety within this set of twelve fantasias. These come off very well in this fine recording by Castillo Hernández, who is not afraid to emphasize the dramatic features of some pieces, such as the opening movement of the Fantasia No. 11. This is a compelling recording, which can compete with any recording that has been released previously.
[1] Alfonso Ferrabosco II: "Music to hear - Music for lyra viol from 1609"
Richard Boothby, Asaka Morikawa, viola da gamba
Signum Classics SIGCD757 (© 2023) details
[2] "Ricercare e Canzoni" (Ortiz, Hume, Hely, Bertalotti)
Matteo Cicchitti, viola da gamba
Challenge Classics CC72918 (© 2022) details
[3] "Viola da gamba - Le Jeu d'Harmonie"
Roberto Gini, viola da gamba
Aulicus Classics ALC 0047 (© 2021) details
[4] Mr. De Machy: "Pieces de Violle"
Shaun Ng, viola da gamba
A415 Music CD006 (© 2022) details
[5] "7 Movements - J.S. Bach, Sainte-Colombe father & son"
Johanna Rose, viola da gamba
Rubicon RCD1101 (© 2022) details
[6] Georg Philipp Telemann: 12 Fantaisies pour la basse de violle
Israel Castillo Hernández, viola da gamba
Urtext JBCC334 (© 2022) details
Friday, July 7, 2023
In praise of the Viennese double bass
The double bass is mainly known as the grumbler in the low department of the orchestra. Very seldom it shines in a solo role. Recently three discs have been released which attest to its qualities as a solo instrument. That is to say, we have to do here with a special kind of double bass (in the liner-notes of one of the discs also called violone), known as 'Viennese double bass'. The booklet to the Glossa disc [1] explains its character: "A special characteristic is its five-string configuration with third-fourth tuning (F-A-D-F#-A), which is documented already in the late seventeenth century. In addition, the instrument was always played with frets, in contrast with the four-string models in the Italian tradition". Chiara Bertoglio [3] explains in what way this allowed this instrument to act in a solo role: "A higher number of strings, in fact, fostered the possibility of quickly spanning large intervals, and consequently of mastering virtuoso passages more easily. Agility was also fostered by the presence of frets and by the shape of the instrument. Frets allowed for a more precise intonation, but also for a technique similar to the guitar’s barré, i.e. the possibility of creating chords by positioning the finger transversely in correspondence of the fret. Moreover, the Viennese violone's silhouette, characterized by a very sloping upper part, permitted to the player to easily reach the high-pitched notes (obtained by pressing the strings in the instrument's lower part)."
Most music for the Viennese double bass was written roughly between 1760 and 1800. That is the time the music on these three discs was written. One of the main protagonists of the Viennese double bass was Johannes Sperger (1750-1812), who was educated at the double bass and was generally considered the greatest player of this instrument of his time. He left a substantial oeuvre, in which 18 concertos for double bass take a special place. The solo parts are demanding and undoubtedly reflect his own skills. Ján Krigovský [2] plays three concertos from his early period (1778/79): the concertos Nos. 3 and 4 appear on disc for the first time, whereas the Concerto No. 2 has been recorded for the first time on period instruments. Sperger's last concerto, which was written in 1807, has been recorded by Isaline Leloup [3], but then in a 'pocket-size' arrangement: the orchestral parts are adapted for string quartet. This was a common practice at the time, and this version is entirely convincing and does not fail to demonstrate the concerto's qualities. Sperger is also included in David Sinclair's recording [1], but then with a piece of chamber music: the Sonata in b minor from 1790 is scored for double bass and cello.
Isaline Leloup included a comparable piece, the Duetto in E flat for viola and double bass by Carl Ditters von Dittersdorf. It closes with a theme with variations, in which the two instruments alternatively play the theme and a variation. The third work on her disc is the Quartet No. 2 in D by Franz Anton Hoffmeister. Quartets for a solo instrument and string trio were very popular during the Classical period. The 'solo instrument' was mostly a flute or an oboe; here it is the double bass.
Sinclair offers two further solo concertos. The Concerto in D by Karl Kohaut, a lutenist by profession, but also a player of the double bass, is one of the earliest concertos for the Viennese double bass, and still has the traces of a baroque concerto. The Concerto in D by Anton Zimmermann was discovered recently and has been recorded by Sinclair for the first time. Zimmermann was a key figure in the orchestra of Pressburg (now Bratislava), where Sperger also spent six years of his life. Sinclair rounds off his programme with two further pieces of chamber music in which the double bass plays the part of another instrument. The Sonata in F was probably written by Andreas Lidl, but is performed here in an adapted version by Franz Xaver Hammer. The solo part was conceived for a viola da gamba. The disc closes with one of Haydn's baryton trios; the double bass takes care of the baryton part.
These three discs are of great importance and offer a fascinating insight into a little-known aspect of the music scene in the Classical period. Each of the pieces performed on these discs is of fine quality, and the solo concertos by Sperger are really exciting stuff. It is probably due to the fact that they require a special kind of double bass that they are not more often performed and recorded. We have here another example of music that only can be performed convincingly with the use of the instruments of the period. All three soloists are excellent in their own right. It is nice that their respective programmes are different, which means that the repertoire available on disc has been substantially increased. Sinclair is accompanied by teachers and former students of the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis, which guarantees high quality and consistency in the interpretation. Ján Krigovský, who is a member of Gunar Letzbor's ensemble Ars Antiqua Austria, and as such mostly plays baroque repertoire, is shining here in later music, with the assistence of Collegium Wartberg 430, an ensemble which plays a wide variety of music on the appropriate instruments. It does an excellent job here. Isaline Leloup has the support of four fine players on violins, viola and cello, and the result is a top-class recording of classical chamber music.
[1] "Wiener Stimmung - Works for the Viennese bass from the late 18th century"
David Sinclair, double bass; Teachers and former students of the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis
Glossa GCD 922524 (© 2022) details
[2] Sperger: "Double bass Concertos"
Ján Krigovský, double bass; Collegium Wartberg 430
Challenge Classics CC72915 (© 2022) details
[3] "A Viennese afternoon - 18th century Viennese bass music"
Isaline Leloup, double bass; Patrick Oliva, Martha Moore, violin; Jean-Philippe Gandit, viola; Ronan Kernoa, cello
Da Vinci Classics C00410 (© 2021) details
Most music for the Viennese double bass was written roughly between 1760 and 1800. That is the time the music on these three discs was written. One of the main protagonists of the Viennese double bass was Johannes Sperger (1750-1812), who was educated at the double bass and was generally considered the greatest player of this instrument of his time. He left a substantial oeuvre, in which 18 concertos for double bass take a special place. The solo parts are demanding and undoubtedly reflect his own skills. Ján Krigovský [2] plays three concertos from his early period (1778/79): the concertos Nos. 3 and 4 appear on disc for the first time, whereas the Concerto No. 2 has been recorded for the first time on period instruments. Sperger's last concerto, which was written in 1807, has been recorded by Isaline Leloup [3], but then in a 'pocket-size' arrangement: the orchestral parts are adapted for string quartet. This was a common practice at the time, and this version is entirely convincing and does not fail to demonstrate the concerto's qualities. Sperger is also included in David Sinclair's recording [1], but then with a piece of chamber music: the Sonata in b minor from 1790 is scored for double bass and cello.
Isaline Leloup included a comparable piece, the Duetto in E flat for viola and double bass by Carl Ditters von Dittersdorf. It closes with a theme with variations, in which the two instruments alternatively play the theme and a variation. The third work on her disc is the Quartet No. 2 in D by Franz Anton Hoffmeister. Quartets for a solo instrument and string trio were very popular during the Classical period. The 'solo instrument' was mostly a flute or an oboe; here it is the double bass.
Sinclair offers two further solo concertos. The Concerto in D by Karl Kohaut, a lutenist by profession, but also a player of the double bass, is one of the earliest concertos for the Viennese double bass, and still has the traces of a baroque concerto. The Concerto in D by Anton Zimmermann was discovered recently and has been recorded by Sinclair for the first time. Zimmermann was a key figure in the orchestra of Pressburg (now Bratislava), where Sperger also spent six years of his life. Sinclair rounds off his programme with two further pieces of chamber music in which the double bass plays the part of another instrument. The Sonata in F was probably written by Andreas Lidl, but is performed here in an adapted version by Franz Xaver Hammer. The solo part was conceived for a viola da gamba. The disc closes with one of Haydn's baryton trios; the double bass takes care of the baryton part.
These three discs are of great importance and offer a fascinating insight into a little-known aspect of the music scene in the Classical period. Each of the pieces performed on these discs is of fine quality, and the solo concertos by Sperger are really exciting stuff. It is probably due to the fact that they require a special kind of double bass that they are not more often performed and recorded. We have here another example of music that only can be performed convincingly with the use of the instruments of the period. All three soloists are excellent in their own right. It is nice that their respective programmes are different, which means that the repertoire available on disc has been substantially increased. Sinclair is accompanied by teachers and former students of the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis, which guarantees high quality and consistency in the interpretation. Ján Krigovský, who is a member of Gunar Letzbor's ensemble Ars Antiqua Austria, and as such mostly plays baroque repertoire, is shining here in later music, with the assistence of Collegium Wartberg 430, an ensemble which plays a wide variety of music on the appropriate instruments. It does an excellent job here. Isaline Leloup has the support of four fine players on violins, viola and cello, and the result is a top-class recording of classical chamber music.
[1] "Wiener Stimmung - Works for the Viennese bass from the late 18th century"
David Sinclair, double bass; Teachers and former students of the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis
Glossa GCD 922524 (© 2022) details
[2] Sperger: "Double bass Concertos"
Ján Krigovský, double bass; Collegium Wartberg 430
Challenge Classics CC72915 (© 2022) details
[3] "A Viennese afternoon - 18th century Viennese bass music"
Isaline Leloup, double bass; Patrick Oliva, Martha Moore, violin; Jean-Philippe Gandit, viola; Ronan Kernoa, cello
Da Vinci Classics C00410 (© 2021) details
Friday, May 19, 2023
The cello in Italy (2)
A few month ago I reviewed several discs with music for the cello by Italian composers from the 18th century. It is quite remarkable how many recordings of this kind of repertoire have been released in recent years. There was too much material for one blog, and therefore I decided to return to it later. In the meantime several more recordings have come my way. Reason enough for a sequel.
Giovanni Battista Sammartini has become best-known for his symphonies, which should have influenced Haydn. However, there is more to him than the symphonies. His oeuvre is large, and includes works in every genre in vogue in his time. The category of chamber music includes six sonatas which were published as his Op. 4, scored for cello and basso continuo. There are some doubts about the authenticity of the sixth sonata of this set, and that also goes for two separate sonatas in G major and G minor respectively. These sonatas share their fate with quite a number of other works attributed to Sammartini, some of which may have been written by his brother Giuseppe. The doubts about the authenticity of three sonatas did not prevent the Ensemble Dolci Accenti [1] from recording them. The disc of the sonatas Op. 4 and the two separate sonatas may well represent all that is or may have been written for the cello by Sammartini, although the booklet does not say so. It also may be the first disc entirely devoted to these sonatas; I only could find a disc of more than twenty years ago on modern instruments, including a piano. It is surprising that they are not more frequently played, because these are fine works, which are written in the galant idiom. That does not mean that they are devoid of expression; the slow movements have plenty of that. Many fast movements have an infectious rhythm, which is perfectly conveyed by the members of the ensemble. This disc is an important addition to the discography of 18th-century music for the cello.
For a long time the viola da gamba was the dominating string bass in England. With time, and largely due to the influx of Italian cellists/composers, this changed, and the cello became an increasingly popular instrument. One of the most prominent lovers of the cello was Frederick, Prince of Wales. He played the instrument himself, and several composers dedicated sonatas for his instrument to him. Among them were Andrea Caporale and John Ernest Galliard, who contributed six sonatas each to a collection, published in 1745. The six by Caporale have been recorded by Renato Criscuolo and the Romabarocca Ensemble [2], who extended their programme with arias from stage works by Handel, which have an obbligato part for the cello, written for Caporale. The latter was not known for his virtuosity, but rather his "full, sweet, and vocal tone", as Charles Burney put it. That comes well off here: these six sonatas are excellent stuff, which largely avoid technical fireworks, but are cantabile in nature. Criscuolo has realized this character perfectly. The idea to include arias by Handel is interesting and praiseworthy, but I am not happy with the choice of Angelo Bonazzoli to sing them. He has a rather small voice, and his singing is marred by an incessant and pretty large vibrato.
Salvatore Lanzetti was from Naples and received his musical education at the Conservatorio di S Maria di Loreto. In 1727 he entered the service of Vittorio Amedeo II in Turin. He held this post until his death, but had many opportunities to perform elsewhere. In the 1740s he lived in London, until at least 1754, and according to Charles Burney he played an important role in the popularization of the cello. He was a great innovator of cello technique, and his sonatas attest to that. Nine of the twelve sonatas Op. 1 consist of three movements; the other three come in four. There is no fixed order: some open with a slow movement, which is followed by two fast movements, whereas others are in the order fast - slow - fast. In 1991 Claudio Ronco [3] recorded the complete set with a traditional basso continuo line-up: cello, theorbo and harpsichord. He continued to study the music, and came to the conclusion that they ask for a performance on two cellos, without chordal instruments. That has resulted in the recording which was released by Urania Records. It is exciting and compelling music, and that is perfectly conveyed by Ronco and Emanuela Vozza. The choice of tempo and the treatment of dynamics result in often quite dramatic readings, which are hard to surpass. It is easy to understand that he was admired in his time.
The name of Dall'Abaco may ring a bell with lovers of baroque music because of the concertos by Evaristo Felice, who for many years was Kapellmeister at the Bavarian court. However, lovers of the cello rather think of his son, Giuseppe Clemente, who was a brilliant cellist. He contributed to the promotion of the cello during his stay in England in 1736/37, where he caught the attention of Charles Burney. In recent years his eleven Capricci for unaccompanied cello have been recorded several times. In comparison, his sonatas with basso continuo have received less attention. Elinor Frey [4], in the liner-notes to her recording of five sonatas, points out the various technical challenges to the interpreter, such as bariolage bowings, double and triple stop passagework and drones using open strings or the thumb. However, these sonatas are not just demonstrations of Dall'Abaco's brilliant technique, but very good and entertaining music. In some movements he may refer to the viola da gamba music of the past, such as in a modo di Viola da gamba (Sonata ABV 35). There are some beautiful galant slow movements, but also exuberant closing movements with influences of traditional music. The closing allegro, with the title La Zampogna, from the Sonata ABV 18 is a kind of Kehraus. All these pieces are brilliantly played. Elinor Frey not only shows her impressive technical skills, but also het obvious enjoyment of this music. She receives excellent support from her colleagues on the second cello, archlute and harpsichord. This is a disc no lover of the cello should miss.
Tommaso Giordani was a very productive composer, in particular of vocal music. He was born in Naples, settled in England in the 1750s and then moved to Dublin. His oeuvre includes a large amount of operas and songs, but also chamber music for various scorings, including string quartets, and keyboard music. There is no indication that he played the cello, but, according to the liner-notes to the recording of his six duets for two cellos by Charlie Rasmussen and Anton TenWolde [5], these pieces show that he must have had a more than average knowledge of the instrument and the way it is played. These duets may have been intended for the large and growing market of amateurs, and also bear witness to the dissemination of the cello on the British isles. The two cellos are treated on equal footing; often they get involved in a kind of dialogue. We may well see here the influence of Giordani's activities in the field of opera. The two cellists deliver outstanding performances; they treat the music exactly according to its intentions. They don't try to make more of it than it pretends to offer. There are no deep thoughts here: this is pure entertainment, and that comes off perfectly here.
Giovanni Battista Cirri was born in Forlì, between Bologna and Rimini, and was educated at the cello. He developed into a virtuoso on his instrument, and started to compose. In the 1760s he was in Paris, where he played at the Concert Spirituel and met, among others, Jean-Pierre Duport. He then moved to England, where he was active as a performer, for instance at the Bach-Abel concerts. He returned to Italy in 1780. Cirri has left a pretty large oeuvre of mainly chamber music, in which the cello plays an important role. The Breaking Bass Ensemble [6] recorded four of the eight duets that were published in London; the year is unknown. The work-list in New Grove does not mention the twelve sonate da camera, four of which are also included here. These were discovered in 2018 and are scored for cello and basso continuo. They were written after Cirri's return to Italy, which makes the scoring with basso continuo rather remarkable. Like the duets they are in three movements; the slow movement is either the first or the second. In the duets the two cellos are treated on equal footing, but sometimes the second acts as an accompaniment of the first. Cirri is not an entirely unknown quantity; some of his sonatas and concertos have been recorded. However, considering the size of his oeuvre, there is still much to discover, and this disc is a very fine addition to the discography. The Breaking Bass Ensemble, with Carlos Montesinos Defez and Guillermo Turina on cello, delivers outstanding performances.
The last recording to be reviewed here is an 'oldie': Roberto Gini [7] recorded four pieces for cello in different scorings as far back as 1992, but these were never released. With this disc we stay with Cirri, but then in different repertoire: the programme opens and closes with concertos for obbligato cello, two violins and bass, which were printed in London; the year of publication is not known. In New Grove they are ranked among the orchestral music, but that is incorrect: these concertos belong among the genre of the concerto da camera, and were undoubtedly intended for a performance with one instrument per part. That is the way they are played here. Cirri's music is mostly written in the galant idiom, and so are these concertos, which are very nice to listen to. Also on this disc is a sonata for keyboard (here harpsichord) and cello by the German composer Johann Melchior Dreyer, who was a prolific composer. He wrote a large amount of sacred music, which fell out of grace in the course of the 19th century. Today only some of his organ music appears in anthologies. Laurent Benosi is an entirely unknown quantity; New Grove does not mention him and the liner-notes - which are very concise anyway - don't include any biographical information. Here we get one of the six duets for two cellos which were published in London as his Op. 1. The fifth of these, performed here, suggests that they are valuable additions to the repertoire for this scoring. Roberto Gini and his colleagues have found exactly the right approach to this repertoire. The result is a fine and entertaining disc, which will give every lover of the cello much to enjoy.
[1] GB Sammartini: "Sonatas for Cello and B.c."
Ensemble Dolci Accenti
Brilliant Classics 96767 (© 2023) details
[2] Caporale: "Cello Sonatas" - Handel: "Arias"
Renato Criscuolo, cello; Angelo Bonazzoli, alto; Romabarocca Ensemble
Brilliant Classics 95622 (© 2019) details
[3] Lanzetti: "12 Cello Sonatas, Op. 1"
Claudio Ronco, Emanuela Vozza, cello
Urania Records LDV 14051 (2 CDs) (© 2019) details
[4] JMC dall'Abaco: "Cello Sonatas"
Elinor Frey, Mauro Valli, cello; Giangiacomo Pinardi, archlute; Federica Bianchi, harpsichord
Passacaille PAS 1069 (© 2020) details
[5] Giordani: "Six Duos for Two Cellos Op. 18"
Charlie Rasmussen, Anton TenWolde, cello
Centaur CRC 3819 (© 2020) details
[6] Cirri: "Sonatas and Duos for Cello"
Breaking Bass Ensemble/Carlos Montesinos Defez, cello
Brilliant Classics 96416 (© 2022) details
[7] "Il violoncello galante"
Ensemble Concerto/Roberto Gini, cello
Aulicus Classics ALC 0058 (© 2021) details
Giovanni Battista Sammartini has become best-known for his symphonies, which should have influenced Haydn. However, there is more to him than the symphonies. His oeuvre is large, and includes works in every genre in vogue in his time. The category of chamber music includes six sonatas which were published as his Op. 4, scored for cello and basso continuo. There are some doubts about the authenticity of the sixth sonata of this set, and that also goes for two separate sonatas in G major and G minor respectively. These sonatas share their fate with quite a number of other works attributed to Sammartini, some of which may have been written by his brother Giuseppe. The doubts about the authenticity of three sonatas did not prevent the Ensemble Dolci Accenti [1] from recording them. The disc of the sonatas Op. 4 and the two separate sonatas may well represent all that is or may have been written for the cello by Sammartini, although the booklet does not say so. It also may be the first disc entirely devoted to these sonatas; I only could find a disc of more than twenty years ago on modern instruments, including a piano. It is surprising that they are not more frequently played, because these are fine works, which are written in the galant idiom. That does not mean that they are devoid of expression; the slow movements have plenty of that. Many fast movements have an infectious rhythm, which is perfectly conveyed by the members of the ensemble. This disc is an important addition to the discography of 18th-century music for the cello.
For a long time the viola da gamba was the dominating string bass in England. With time, and largely due to the influx of Italian cellists/composers, this changed, and the cello became an increasingly popular instrument. One of the most prominent lovers of the cello was Frederick, Prince of Wales. He played the instrument himself, and several composers dedicated sonatas for his instrument to him. Among them were Andrea Caporale and John Ernest Galliard, who contributed six sonatas each to a collection, published in 1745. The six by Caporale have been recorded by Renato Criscuolo and the Romabarocca Ensemble [2], who extended their programme with arias from stage works by Handel, which have an obbligato part for the cello, written for Caporale. The latter was not known for his virtuosity, but rather his "full, sweet, and vocal tone", as Charles Burney put it. That comes well off here: these six sonatas are excellent stuff, which largely avoid technical fireworks, but are cantabile in nature. Criscuolo has realized this character perfectly. The idea to include arias by Handel is interesting and praiseworthy, but I am not happy with the choice of Angelo Bonazzoli to sing them. He has a rather small voice, and his singing is marred by an incessant and pretty large vibrato.
Salvatore Lanzetti was from Naples and received his musical education at the Conservatorio di S Maria di Loreto. In 1727 he entered the service of Vittorio Amedeo II in Turin. He held this post until his death, but had many opportunities to perform elsewhere. In the 1740s he lived in London, until at least 1754, and according to Charles Burney he played an important role in the popularization of the cello. He was a great innovator of cello technique, and his sonatas attest to that. Nine of the twelve sonatas Op. 1 consist of three movements; the other three come in four. There is no fixed order: some open with a slow movement, which is followed by two fast movements, whereas others are in the order fast - slow - fast. In 1991 Claudio Ronco [3] recorded the complete set with a traditional basso continuo line-up: cello, theorbo and harpsichord. He continued to study the music, and came to the conclusion that they ask for a performance on two cellos, without chordal instruments. That has resulted in the recording which was released by Urania Records. It is exciting and compelling music, and that is perfectly conveyed by Ronco and Emanuela Vozza. The choice of tempo and the treatment of dynamics result in often quite dramatic readings, which are hard to surpass. It is easy to understand that he was admired in his time.
The name of Dall'Abaco may ring a bell with lovers of baroque music because of the concertos by Evaristo Felice, who for many years was Kapellmeister at the Bavarian court. However, lovers of the cello rather think of his son, Giuseppe Clemente, who was a brilliant cellist. He contributed to the promotion of the cello during his stay in England in 1736/37, where he caught the attention of Charles Burney. In recent years his eleven Capricci for unaccompanied cello have been recorded several times. In comparison, his sonatas with basso continuo have received less attention. Elinor Frey [4], in the liner-notes to her recording of five sonatas, points out the various technical challenges to the interpreter, such as bariolage bowings, double and triple stop passagework and drones using open strings or the thumb. However, these sonatas are not just demonstrations of Dall'Abaco's brilliant technique, but very good and entertaining music. In some movements he may refer to the viola da gamba music of the past, such as in a modo di Viola da gamba (Sonata ABV 35). There are some beautiful galant slow movements, but also exuberant closing movements with influences of traditional music. The closing allegro, with the title La Zampogna, from the Sonata ABV 18 is a kind of Kehraus. All these pieces are brilliantly played. Elinor Frey not only shows her impressive technical skills, but also het obvious enjoyment of this music. She receives excellent support from her colleagues on the second cello, archlute and harpsichord. This is a disc no lover of the cello should miss.
Tommaso Giordani was a very productive composer, in particular of vocal music. He was born in Naples, settled in England in the 1750s and then moved to Dublin. His oeuvre includes a large amount of operas and songs, but also chamber music for various scorings, including string quartets, and keyboard music. There is no indication that he played the cello, but, according to the liner-notes to the recording of his six duets for two cellos by Charlie Rasmussen and Anton TenWolde [5], these pieces show that he must have had a more than average knowledge of the instrument and the way it is played. These duets may have been intended for the large and growing market of amateurs, and also bear witness to the dissemination of the cello on the British isles. The two cellos are treated on equal footing; often they get involved in a kind of dialogue. We may well see here the influence of Giordani's activities in the field of opera. The two cellists deliver outstanding performances; they treat the music exactly according to its intentions. They don't try to make more of it than it pretends to offer. There are no deep thoughts here: this is pure entertainment, and that comes off perfectly here.
Giovanni Battista Cirri was born in Forlì, between Bologna and Rimini, and was educated at the cello. He developed into a virtuoso on his instrument, and started to compose. In the 1760s he was in Paris, where he played at the Concert Spirituel and met, among others, Jean-Pierre Duport. He then moved to England, where he was active as a performer, for instance at the Bach-Abel concerts. He returned to Italy in 1780. Cirri has left a pretty large oeuvre of mainly chamber music, in which the cello plays an important role. The Breaking Bass Ensemble [6] recorded four of the eight duets that were published in London; the year is unknown. The work-list in New Grove does not mention the twelve sonate da camera, four of which are also included here. These were discovered in 2018 and are scored for cello and basso continuo. They were written after Cirri's return to Italy, which makes the scoring with basso continuo rather remarkable. Like the duets they are in three movements; the slow movement is either the first or the second. In the duets the two cellos are treated on equal footing, but sometimes the second acts as an accompaniment of the first. Cirri is not an entirely unknown quantity; some of his sonatas and concertos have been recorded. However, considering the size of his oeuvre, there is still much to discover, and this disc is a very fine addition to the discography. The Breaking Bass Ensemble, with Carlos Montesinos Defez and Guillermo Turina on cello, delivers outstanding performances.
The last recording to be reviewed here is an 'oldie': Roberto Gini [7] recorded four pieces for cello in different scorings as far back as 1992, but these were never released. With this disc we stay with Cirri, but then in different repertoire: the programme opens and closes with concertos for obbligato cello, two violins and bass, which were printed in London; the year of publication is not known. In New Grove they are ranked among the orchestral music, but that is incorrect: these concertos belong among the genre of the concerto da camera, and were undoubtedly intended for a performance with one instrument per part. That is the way they are played here. Cirri's music is mostly written in the galant idiom, and so are these concertos, which are very nice to listen to. Also on this disc is a sonata for keyboard (here harpsichord) and cello by the German composer Johann Melchior Dreyer, who was a prolific composer. He wrote a large amount of sacred music, which fell out of grace in the course of the 19th century. Today only some of his organ music appears in anthologies. Laurent Benosi is an entirely unknown quantity; New Grove does not mention him and the liner-notes - which are very concise anyway - don't include any biographical information. Here we get one of the six duets for two cellos which were published in London as his Op. 1. The fifth of these, performed here, suggests that they are valuable additions to the repertoire for this scoring. Roberto Gini and his colleagues have found exactly the right approach to this repertoire. The result is a fine and entertaining disc, which will give every lover of the cello much to enjoy.
[1] GB Sammartini: "Sonatas for Cello and B.c."
Ensemble Dolci Accenti
Brilliant Classics 96767 (© 2023) details
[2] Caporale: "Cello Sonatas" - Handel: "Arias"
Renato Criscuolo, cello; Angelo Bonazzoli, alto; Romabarocca Ensemble
Brilliant Classics 95622 (© 2019) details
[3] Lanzetti: "12 Cello Sonatas, Op. 1"
Claudio Ronco, Emanuela Vozza, cello
Urania Records LDV 14051 (2 CDs) (© 2019) details
[4] JMC dall'Abaco: "Cello Sonatas"
Elinor Frey, Mauro Valli, cello; Giangiacomo Pinardi, archlute; Federica Bianchi, harpsichord
Passacaille PAS 1069 (© 2020) details
[5] Giordani: "Six Duos for Two Cellos Op. 18"
Charlie Rasmussen, Anton TenWolde, cello
Centaur CRC 3819 (© 2020) details
[6] Cirri: "Sonatas and Duos for Cello"
Breaking Bass Ensemble/Carlos Montesinos Defez, cello
Brilliant Classics 96416 (© 2022) details
[7] "Il violoncello galante"
Ensemble Concerto/Roberto Gini, cello
Aulicus Classics ALC 0058 (© 2021) details
Saturday, February 25, 2023
The cello in Italy (1)
The history of the cello, which has played such an important role at the music scene until the present day, is rather complicated. String bass instruments were used since the renaissance, but their names often cause confusion. The baroque cello as we know it today, made its appearance in the last quarter of the 17th century in Italy. At that time the most common string bass was called violone, but it seems likely that the word violoncello and violone were sometimes interchangeable. One of the pioneers of the cello was Domenico Gabrielli, but whether he played the instrument now known as cello or rather the old violone, is hard to decide. Anyway, whereas his small oeuvre for the 'cello' is rather well-known and available in several recordings, not often they are played on the violone. Alessandro Palmeri [1] plays a splendid historical instrument, built in Rome in 1685 by Simone Cimapane. He put together a programme around Corelli, although only some of the composers had any ties with him. This disc rather gives us some idea of what was going on at Corelli's time in Rome, but also in Bologna, where Gabrielli, Pietro Giuseppe Gaetano Boni and Giovanni Battista Vitali were active. An interesting piece is Tromba per il violone, by Giuseppe Colomba from Modena, in which the trumpet is imitated. Palmeri is an excellent player, and his colleagues deliver appropriate support.
The next disc is devoted to two virtuosic cellists: Giovanni and Antonio Maria Bononcini. They were famous in this capacity, but until recently only one piece for the cello by Giovanni was known: the Sonata in a minor, included in a collection of six cello sonatas by different composers. However, as two movements show strong similarity with movements from Jean-Marie Leclair's Violin sonata Op. 1 No. 8, there are considerable doubts about its authenticy. That makes the discovery of two Sinfonias for cello and basso continuo, which have been recorded for the first time by the Accademia Ottoboni [2], with Marco Ceccato on the cello, all the more important. In particular the Sinfonia in D includes several technical challenges, which shed light on the composer's own skills. His younger brother Antonio Maria has left a substantial number of pieces for the cello and is represented with three sonatas and a sinfonia of different character. In particular the Sonata IV in a minor from a set of twelve, dating from around 1693, shows the virtuosity for which he was known, for instance in the application of double stopping, tremolos and repeated notes. This piece is also notable for its harmonic progressions. Don't be afraid that the pieces on this disc are only about technique: there are many movements of wonderful lyricism. All the features of these sonatas and sinfonias come perfectly off in these outstanding performances.
Giovanni Bononcini turns up again in the programme recorded by Fondo Barocco [3]. The liner-notes don't mention the doubt about the authenticity of the piece. Also included are two further sonatas from the collection, in which Bononcini's sonata is the first. Giuseppe Sammartini is not known for having played the cello; he rather was an oboist, and a famous one at that. Next to nothing is known about Wenceslaus Spourni, a cellist of Bohemian origin, who worked in Paris. Antonio Caldara, who has become best-known as one of the central figures at the imperial court in Vienna, was educated as a cellist, but only late in his career he wrote cello sonatas, at the request of Count Rudolf Franz Erwein von Schönborn-Wiesentheid, an ardent lover of the cello and a skilfull amateur player of the instrument, whose archive includes so many treasures for cello and other instruments. What makes this disc special is the way the sonatas are performed. Fondo Barocco consists of just two players: Marie Orsini-Rosenberg (cello) and Herwig Neugebauer (violone). The latter does not play the violone used in modern orchestral performances; that is a 16' instrument. Neugebauer plays an 8' violone in G, whose pitch is comparable to that of the cello. Performing the bass line with just one string bass instrument was quite common at the time, but is seldom practised today. The performers admit that not every sonata can be performed that way; sometimes one simply needs the harmony of a keyboard or plucked instrument. In the sonatas played here this combination works wonderfully well, also thanks to the engaging manner in which the two artist interpret their programme. This is a very fine and entertaining disc, which will give any lover of the cello much pleasure.
A composer who substantially contributed to the repertoire for the cello was Giovanni Benedetto Platti. His oeuvre includes a large number of cello concertos and sonatas for cello and basso continuo. In addition he wrote sonatas for several instruments with obbligato cello parts. Whether this was due to his personal predilection for the cello is hard to prove; his reputation based first and foremost on his skills as an oboist. He played several other instruments, including the violin, the cello and the harpsichord. There is no doubt that his music for the cello was written because of his close connection to the above-mentioned Count Rudolf Franz Erwein von Schönborn-Wiesentheid, whom he may have accompanied while the latter was playing the cello. The archive of the Count includes the set of twelve sonatas that Francesco Galligioni [4] recorded for Brilliant Classics. The first six are generally somewhat longer and more lyrical than the remaining six, which include more technical challenges. Interestingly, in some of the sonatas the cello is accompanied by the violone, without a keyboard instrument, comparable with the practice in the Fondo Barocco recording. The difference is that here the violone is a 16' instrument. These twelve sonatas show that Platti was an outstanding composer, and there are many movements which attest to his great melodic gifts. Their qualities come off to full extent under the hands of Galligioni, an excellent and stylish interpreter. This set of two discs is interesting and musically compelling, thanks to Platti and the interpreters.
The last composer in this review is someone who may not ring a bell with many music lovers. If the name of Antonio Vandini may sound familiar, it is mainly because he was a close friend of Giuseppe Tartini, and as such he may be mentioned in articles on that great violinist and composer. They often performed together, across Italy and also elsewhere, for instance in Prague. Little is known about his early years, and the liner-notes in the two recordings reviewed here, express different views on aspects of his biography, for instance about who may have been his teacher, and whether he and Vivaldi knew each other and the latter did write some of his cello concertos for him. There is no difference of opinion on two aspects of performance practice. Although some of Vandini's works seem to suggest that they were intended for the five-string cello, both cellists opted for the four-string cello, for historical and technical reasons. Vandini is known to have played the cello in the old-fashioned way, in the underhand grip, like gambists do. Elinor Frey [5] practises this grip in three of the six sonatas and the only concerto. Francesco Galligioni [6], on the other hand, plays this way in all the pieces. The result is a sound that is something between the 'conventional' (baroque) cello and the viola da gamba. There are substantial differences in the performances, for instance in the choice of tempi. Frey is accompanied by different instruments, varying from one sonata to the other, including a second cello, a viola da gamba and a double bass. Galligioni is supported by organ or harpsichord, and in some sonatas by a bassoon. The latter option seems rather odd. The miking is very close, and the acoustic rather dry, which is not very pleasant to listen to. His articulation and dynamic shading are less differentated than Frey's. Overall I tend to prefer the latter's performances, but Galligioni has also something to offer that may appeal to cello aficionados.
[1] "Il Violoncello di Corelli"
Alessandro Palmieri, violone; Takashi Kaketa, cello; Riccardo Doni, harpsichord, organ
Passacaille PAS 1099 (© 2021) details
[2] G & AM Bononcini: "Cello Sonatas"
Marco Ceccato, cello; Accademia Ottoboni
Alpha 826 (© 2022) details
[3] "Baroque Cello Sonatas"
Fondo Barocco
Orlando Records OR0047 (© 2021) details
[4] Platti: "Cello Sonatas"
Francesco Galligioni, cello; members of L'Arte dell'Arco
Brilliant Classics 95763 (© 2019) details
[5] Vandini: "Complete Works"
Elinor Frey, cello; Isabella Bison, Lorenzo Gugole, violin; Maria Bocelli, viola; Marc Vanscheeuwijck, cello [bc]; Patxi Montero, viola da gamba, double bass; Federica Bianchi, harpsichord
Passacaille PAS 1079 (© 2021) details
[6] Vandini: "Complete Works"
Francesco Galligioni, cello; L'arte dell'Arco
Dynamic CDS7890 (© 2020) details
The next disc is devoted to two virtuosic cellists: Giovanni and Antonio Maria Bononcini. They were famous in this capacity, but until recently only one piece for the cello by Giovanni was known: the Sonata in a minor, included in a collection of six cello sonatas by different composers. However, as two movements show strong similarity with movements from Jean-Marie Leclair's Violin sonata Op. 1 No. 8, there are considerable doubts about its authenticy. That makes the discovery of two Sinfonias for cello and basso continuo, which have been recorded for the first time by the Accademia Ottoboni [2], with Marco Ceccato on the cello, all the more important. In particular the Sinfonia in D includes several technical challenges, which shed light on the composer's own skills. His younger brother Antonio Maria has left a substantial number of pieces for the cello and is represented with three sonatas and a sinfonia of different character. In particular the Sonata IV in a minor from a set of twelve, dating from around 1693, shows the virtuosity for which he was known, for instance in the application of double stopping, tremolos and repeated notes. This piece is also notable for its harmonic progressions. Don't be afraid that the pieces on this disc are only about technique: there are many movements of wonderful lyricism. All the features of these sonatas and sinfonias come perfectly off in these outstanding performances.
Giovanni Bononcini turns up again in the programme recorded by Fondo Barocco [3]. The liner-notes don't mention the doubt about the authenticity of the piece. Also included are two further sonatas from the collection, in which Bononcini's sonata is the first. Giuseppe Sammartini is not known for having played the cello; he rather was an oboist, and a famous one at that. Next to nothing is known about Wenceslaus Spourni, a cellist of Bohemian origin, who worked in Paris. Antonio Caldara, who has become best-known as one of the central figures at the imperial court in Vienna, was educated as a cellist, but only late in his career he wrote cello sonatas, at the request of Count Rudolf Franz Erwein von Schönborn-Wiesentheid, an ardent lover of the cello and a skilfull amateur player of the instrument, whose archive includes so many treasures for cello and other instruments. What makes this disc special is the way the sonatas are performed. Fondo Barocco consists of just two players: Marie Orsini-Rosenberg (cello) and Herwig Neugebauer (violone). The latter does not play the violone used in modern orchestral performances; that is a 16' instrument. Neugebauer plays an 8' violone in G, whose pitch is comparable to that of the cello. Performing the bass line with just one string bass instrument was quite common at the time, but is seldom practised today. The performers admit that not every sonata can be performed that way; sometimes one simply needs the harmony of a keyboard or plucked instrument. In the sonatas played here this combination works wonderfully well, also thanks to the engaging manner in which the two artist interpret their programme. This is a very fine and entertaining disc, which will give any lover of the cello much pleasure.
A composer who substantially contributed to the repertoire for the cello was Giovanni Benedetto Platti. His oeuvre includes a large number of cello concertos and sonatas for cello and basso continuo. In addition he wrote sonatas for several instruments with obbligato cello parts. Whether this was due to his personal predilection for the cello is hard to prove; his reputation based first and foremost on his skills as an oboist. He played several other instruments, including the violin, the cello and the harpsichord. There is no doubt that his music for the cello was written because of his close connection to the above-mentioned Count Rudolf Franz Erwein von Schönborn-Wiesentheid, whom he may have accompanied while the latter was playing the cello. The archive of the Count includes the set of twelve sonatas that Francesco Galligioni [4] recorded for Brilliant Classics. The first six are generally somewhat longer and more lyrical than the remaining six, which include more technical challenges. Interestingly, in some of the sonatas the cello is accompanied by the violone, without a keyboard instrument, comparable with the practice in the Fondo Barocco recording. The difference is that here the violone is a 16' instrument. These twelve sonatas show that Platti was an outstanding composer, and there are many movements which attest to his great melodic gifts. Their qualities come off to full extent under the hands of Galligioni, an excellent and stylish interpreter. This set of two discs is interesting and musically compelling, thanks to Platti and the interpreters.
The last composer in this review is someone who may not ring a bell with many music lovers. If the name of Antonio Vandini may sound familiar, it is mainly because he was a close friend of Giuseppe Tartini, and as such he may be mentioned in articles on that great violinist and composer. They often performed together, across Italy and also elsewhere, for instance in Prague. Little is known about his early years, and the liner-notes in the two recordings reviewed here, express different views on aspects of his biography, for instance about who may have been his teacher, and whether he and Vivaldi knew each other and the latter did write some of his cello concertos for him. There is no difference of opinion on two aspects of performance practice. Although some of Vandini's works seem to suggest that they were intended for the five-string cello, both cellists opted for the four-string cello, for historical and technical reasons. Vandini is known to have played the cello in the old-fashioned way, in the underhand grip, like gambists do. Elinor Frey [5] practises this grip in three of the six sonatas and the only concerto. Francesco Galligioni [6], on the other hand, plays this way in all the pieces. The result is a sound that is something between the 'conventional' (baroque) cello and the viola da gamba. There are substantial differences in the performances, for instance in the choice of tempi. Frey is accompanied by different instruments, varying from one sonata to the other, including a second cello, a viola da gamba and a double bass. Galligioni is supported by organ or harpsichord, and in some sonatas by a bassoon. The latter option seems rather odd. The miking is very close, and the acoustic rather dry, which is not very pleasant to listen to. His articulation and dynamic shading are less differentated than Frey's. Overall I tend to prefer the latter's performances, but Galligioni has also something to offer that may appeal to cello aficionados.
[1] "Il Violoncello di Corelli"
Alessandro Palmieri, violone; Takashi Kaketa, cello; Riccardo Doni, harpsichord, organ
Passacaille PAS 1099 (© 2021) details
[2] G & AM Bononcini: "Cello Sonatas"
Marco Ceccato, cello; Accademia Ottoboni
Alpha 826 (© 2022) details
[3] "Baroque Cello Sonatas"
Fondo Barocco
Orlando Records OR0047 (© 2021) details
[4] Platti: "Cello Sonatas"
Francesco Galligioni, cello; members of L'Arte dell'Arco
Brilliant Classics 95763 (© 2019) details
[5] Vandini: "Complete Works"
Elinor Frey, cello; Isabella Bison, Lorenzo Gugole, violin; Maria Bocelli, viola; Marc Vanscheeuwijck, cello [bc]; Patxi Montero, viola da gamba, double bass; Federica Bianchi, harpsichord
Passacaille PAS 1079 (© 2021) details
[6] Vandini: "Complete Works"
Francesco Galligioni, cello; L'arte dell'Arco
Dynamic CDS7890 (© 2020) details
Friday, January 6, 2023
Rameau and Gluck
Jean-Philippe Rameau is now considered one of the greatest opera composers in history. That was not always the case. In the early stages of his career, his stage works were not always well received. His style was considered too complicated. He was ahead of his time and only later did he gain recognition. But even at that time the libretti were critically received. On the other hand, everyone agreed that he was a brilliant orchestrator. This is demonstrated in the 'Nouvelle Symphonie' recorded by Marc Minkowski with his orchestra Les Musiciens du Louvre [1]. The title links this disc to the 'Symphonie imaginaire' that he recorded in 2002. That was on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of his orchestra. Incidentally, the word 'symphony' has nothing to do with the symphony as it arose around the middle of the 18th century and led to the great works of the late 18th and 19th centuries. In Baroque France it was used for an instrumental ensemble in general. One finds it, for example, in the chamber cantatas, in which the voice is accompanied by a 'symphony'. The program begins and ends with excerpts from Castor et Pollux. However, it begins with the overture of the first version (1737) and ends with three instrumental movements from the 1754 version (with an aria from the first). As the program progresses, one hears how the orchestra has changed in Rameau's works. In Rameau's oeuvre, the clarinet finds its way into the French opera orchestra. In his oeuvre the orchestra also plays a dramatic role. In this recording, the overture to Acanthe et Céphise (1751) may serve as a model for Rameau's new treatment of the orchestra. Minkowski has provided a compelling and fascinating musical portrait of the composer here, making it clear that Rameau is rightly regarded as a key figure in the development of orchestration. No wonder someone like Claude Debussy was deeply impressed by Rameau's music. Florian Sempey sings some arias from Les Paladins, Les Indes Galantes, Dardanus and - as I already mentioned - Castor et Pollux. The drama comes through very well, but stylistically I'm less impressed with his performances. In addition, when he sings loudly, his voice has an unpleasant sharpness. The booklet includes the lyrics, with translations in English and German, but unfortunately one is left in the dark about the dramatic context. That is a problem for those who don't know Rameau's operas. But the most important thing are the instrumental movements, and that part of this recording leaves nothing to be desired.
Since the rediscovery of baroque opera, several recordings have been made that are dedicated to a singer who performed in the operas of the time. Among them are mainly sopranos and castrati. Almost without exception, the operas are Italian. In comparison, the singers who performed in French operas are much less well known. Dedicating a recording with arias to them is not that easy, because in French operas the solos are much more embedded in the whole than in Italian operas, and the text also relates much more to the dramatic development of the work. And so it is not surprising that the CD 'Rameau triomphant' [2] mainly contains scenes instead of isolated arias. They are often closely linked to the dances that are so typical of French opera. Another feature is that a singer and the chorus often appear together, whereas most Italian operas include only a few choruses, mostly just one at the close, to be sung by the soloists in ensemble. And then there is the typical French voice type of haute-contre. Mathias Vidal sings solos from ten different operas and the acte de ballet Pygmalion, in which the haute-contre takes on a role. In an interview in the libretto, he explains that Rameau uses this type of voice in different ways, and that the different tessitura of the roles correspond to their weight. Unfortunately, this weight is not mentioned for the individual roles. Almost in passing, it is noted that several roles were played by the haute-contre Pierre de Jélyotte, famous in Rameau's time, but which roles he sang is not mentioned either. The fact that scenes have been taken out of their dramatic context is not unproblematic. Some dance interludes are played relatively slowly. That may make sense in a dramatic context, but when they are isolated from their context the tempos seem rather unnatural. Mathias Vidal is an experienced singer who has often sung important roles in French operas and here - despite the limitations of the concept - he knows how to convince and to show to what extent the singers contributed to the success of an opera. His tessitura and the way he deals with the top notes is impressive. In doing so, he avoids the shouting that other singers think they need to emphasize the dramatic character of an aria. There is a little too much vibrato here and there, but overall it doesn't detract from the persuasiveness of this production. Vidal receives fine support from the ensemble Marguerite Louise under the direction of Gaétan Jarry. It's just a pity that the booklet is a bit sloppy, at least as far as the English translation is concerned. The dances are also mentioned in the libretto and these are also translated. There is no need to translate 'gavotte vive' as 'lively gavotte' or 'Calme des sense (Air tendre)' as 'Calm of the senses (tender air). More serious is that in some cases 'air' is translated as 'aria', which is simply wrong, as this suggests a vocal piece. In French operas this refers to an air de mouvement or air à jouer. It is basically impossible to translate, as there are no equivalents in other music. (By the way, the German translation is even worse. Fortunately, the music and interpretation are much better.
The last disc to be reviewed here was inspired by another singer of the 18th century: Henri Larrivée, a baritone who was initially a singer in the choir of the Opéra and then sang as a soloist in Rameau's Castor et Pollux in 1755. He later took on roles in Hippolyte et Aricie, Dardanus and Zoroastre. But he also sang in operas by other composers, including Gluck, whom he greatly admired. Hence these two composers come together on a CD entitled 'Enfers' [3] - the French word 'enfer' means 'hell'. According to my dictionary it has no plural, and the fact that it is used here in the plural is probably due to the fact that we are hearing excerpts from various operas in which hell or the underworld plays a role. The programme is designed in an unusual way: as a kind of mass, with spiritual and secular elements. Raphaël Pichon was inspired to do this by an anonymously transmitted Requiem Mass based on material from Rameau's opera Castor et Pollux. The pieces are arranged according to the parts of the Requiem Mass. The sequence (Dies irae) opens with an 'sinfonie infernale' from Gluck's Orphée et Euridice (the French version of Orfeo ed Euridice), followed by excerpts from Zoroastre. Of course, the Dance of the Furies is also included in this section. The conclusion is an aria by Pluto and an ensemble of the Fates from Hippolyte et Aricie. This way of working out the concept did not particularly convince me. I find the mixture of spiritual and secular elements somewhat unfortunate. I am more positive about the interpretations by Stéphane Degout and choir and orchestra of Pygmalion. Degout has projected himself into the various roles very well and depicts them as well as is possible in excerpts. There are also short solos by some colleagues; among them, Emmanuelle de Negri and Reinoud Van Mechelen in particular stand out. The musical qualities of the operas by Rameau and Gluck are convincingly demonstrated in this production.
Rameau: "Nouvelle Symphonie"
Florian Sempey, baritone; Les Musiciens du Louvre/Marc Minkowski
Château de Versailles Spectacles CVS062 (© 2022) details
"Rameau triomphant"
Mathias Vidal, haute-contre; Marguerite Louise/Gaétan Jarry
Château de Versailles Spectacles CVS039 (©2021) details
"Enfers - Famous opera scenes by Rameau and Gluck"
Stéphane Degout, baritone; Pygmalion/Raphaël Pichon
Harmonia mundi HMM 902288 (2016; 79') details
Since the rediscovery of baroque opera, several recordings have been made that are dedicated to a singer who performed in the operas of the time. Among them are mainly sopranos and castrati. Almost without exception, the operas are Italian. In comparison, the singers who performed in French operas are much less well known. Dedicating a recording with arias to them is not that easy, because in French operas the solos are much more embedded in the whole than in Italian operas, and the text also relates much more to the dramatic development of the work. And so it is not surprising that the CD 'Rameau triomphant' [2] mainly contains scenes instead of isolated arias. They are often closely linked to the dances that are so typical of French opera. Another feature is that a singer and the chorus often appear together, whereas most Italian operas include only a few choruses, mostly just one at the close, to be sung by the soloists in ensemble. And then there is the typical French voice type of haute-contre. Mathias Vidal sings solos from ten different operas and the acte de ballet Pygmalion, in which the haute-contre takes on a role. In an interview in the libretto, he explains that Rameau uses this type of voice in different ways, and that the different tessitura of the roles correspond to their weight. Unfortunately, this weight is not mentioned for the individual roles. Almost in passing, it is noted that several roles were played by the haute-contre Pierre de Jélyotte, famous in Rameau's time, but which roles he sang is not mentioned either. The fact that scenes have been taken out of their dramatic context is not unproblematic. Some dance interludes are played relatively slowly. That may make sense in a dramatic context, but when they are isolated from their context the tempos seem rather unnatural. Mathias Vidal is an experienced singer who has often sung important roles in French operas and here - despite the limitations of the concept - he knows how to convince and to show to what extent the singers contributed to the success of an opera. His tessitura and the way he deals with the top notes is impressive. In doing so, he avoids the shouting that other singers think they need to emphasize the dramatic character of an aria. There is a little too much vibrato here and there, but overall it doesn't detract from the persuasiveness of this production. Vidal receives fine support from the ensemble Marguerite Louise under the direction of Gaétan Jarry. It's just a pity that the booklet is a bit sloppy, at least as far as the English translation is concerned. The dances are also mentioned in the libretto and these are also translated. There is no need to translate 'gavotte vive' as 'lively gavotte' or 'Calme des sense (Air tendre)' as 'Calm of the senses (tender air). More serious is that in some cases 'air' is translated as 'aria', which is simply wrong, as this suggests a vocal piece. In French operas this refers to an air de mouvement or air à jouer. It is basically impossible to translate, as there are no equivalents in other music. (By the way, the German translation is even worse. Fortunately, the music and interpretation are much better.
The last disc to be reviewed here was inspired by another singer of the 18th century: Henri Larrivée, a baritone who was initially a singer in the choir of the Opéra and then sang as a soloist in Rameau's Castor et Pollux in 1755. He later took on roles in Hippolyte et Aricie, Dardanus and Zoroastre. But he also sang in operas by other composers, including Gluck, whom he greatly admired. Hence these two composers come together on a CD entitled 'Enfers' [3] - the French word 'enfer' means 'hell'. According to my dictionary it has no plural, and the fact that it is used here in the plural is probably due to the fact that we are hearing excerpts from various operas in which hell or the underworld plays a role. The programme is designed in an unusual way: as a kind of mass, with spiritual and secular elements. Raphaël Pichon was inspired to do this by an anonymously transmitted Requiem Mass based on material from Rameau's opera Castor et Pollux. The pieces are arranged according to the parts of the Requiem Mass. The sequence (Dies irae) opens with an 'sinfonie infernale' from Gluck's Orphée et Euridice (the French version of Orfeo ed Euridice), followed by excerpts from Zoroastre. Of course, the Dance of the Furies is also included in this section. The conclusion is an aria by Pluto and an ensemble of the Fates from Hippolyte et Aricie. This way of working out the concept did not particularly convince me. I find the mixture of spiritual and secular elements somewhat unfortunate. I am more positive about the interpretations by Stéphane Degout and choir and orchestra of Pygmalion. Degout has projected himself into the various roles very well and depicts them as well as is possible in excerpts. There are also short solos by some colleagues; among them, Emmanuelle de Negri and Reinoud Van Mechelen in particular stand out. The musical qualities of the operas by Rameau and Gluck are convincingly demonstrated in this production.
Rameau: "Nouvelle Symphonie"
Florian Sempey, baritone; Les Musiciens du Louvre/Marc Minkowski
Château de Versailles Spectacles CVS062 (© 2022) details
"Rameau triomphant"
Mathias Vidal, haute-contre; Marguerite Louise/Gaétan Jarry
Château de Versailles Spectacles CVS039 (©2021) details
"Enfers - Famous opera scenes by Rameau and Gluck"
Stéphane Degout, baritone; Pygmalion/Raphaël Pichon
Harmonia mundi HMM 902288 (2016; 79') details
Friday, November 4, 2022
Bach and the recorder
In my previous blog I reviewed several discs with music transcribed for keyboard. Recorder players are also keen transcribers as they find that there is not enough music for their instrument, especially in the repertoire of the 18th century. The recorder was one of the main instruments of the Renaissance and was still frequently played during the 17th century. It lost its appeal to composers after 1700, when the transverse flute became increasingly popular. Again, Bach is one of the most frequently-transcribed composers: almost anyone wants to play some music by him, but unfortunately he did not serve recorder players very well. Their instrument is given parts in some of the Brandenburg Concertos and participates in a number of cantatas, but there are no sonatas for recorder, neither solo nor trio sonatas. There are quite a number of recordings on the market, in which recorder players perform Bach's sonatas for transverse flute. Those are also included in the recordings which are the subject of this blog, but they cover a wider range of repertoire.
Stefano Bagliano and Andrea Coen [1] play three of Bach's flute sonatas, However, one of them, included as BWV 1020 in the Schmieder catalogue, is probably not from JS Bach's pen, but rather written by his son Carl Philipp Emanuel. It is scored for an obbligato harpsichord and flute; in this performance Bagliano plays a soprano recorder which produces a rather penetrating sound, at the cost of the harpsichord. Given that all the parts are treated on equal footing by the composer, that is a problem. The balance between the recorder and the organ is generally better, especially if Bagliano plays an alto recorder. The repertoire is unusual: I can't remember ever having heard some of the 3-part Sinfonias and contrapuncti from Die Kunst der Fuge in a performance by recorder and keyboard. In the Sonata BWV 1032 the recorder is accompanied by the organ in the first two movements, but by the harpsichord in the third, which is rather unsatisfying. The playing leaves nothing to be desired, but all in all I am not really convinced by this recording.
It is no coincidence that the organ is a better match for the recorder than the harpsichord. Both are wind instruments, and the recorder can sound like one of the stops of the organ. The balance is generally better, as the next disc shows. Agnès Blanche Marc and Helene von Rechenberg [2] confine themselves to the oeuvre of Bach and play three of his chamber works for transverse flute(s): BWV 1030, 1031 and 1039. The have extended their programme with the triosonata for organ BWV 527 and the chorale trio Herr Jesu Christ, dich zu uns wend (BWV 655). In these two pieces Ms Marc plays a soprano recorder, and even here it is too dominant, although that may well be due to the recording. In the trio sonata this damages the equal role of all three parts. In the chorale trio it would not be that much of a problem, if the recorder would play the cantus firmus, but here it plays the upper part. The effect is that it overshadows the cantus firmus played at a lower pitch at the organ. I am hesitant to rank this recording among those in the tradition of historical performance practice. The booklet mentions the recorders that are used here, but not whether they are copies of historical instruments. The organ definitely is no historical instrument: It was originally built in 1930 and has been rebuilt in 1983/84; a number of pipes from the old organ were included. Parts of the rebuilt instrument have "a classic 'neo-baroque' disposition", according to the booklet. Those are not the features which makes it suitable for a performance that does justice to the baroque performance practice. Obviously, the organ is in modern pitch and has an equal temperament. That is not what is required in a performance of music by Bach. It results in performances that are a bit dull, even though the playing is alright.
The last two discs have much in common: Bach is in the centre of attention, and the instruments are recorder and lute. This turns out to be a pretty much ideal partnership. Under the title 'Dialogues' Dorothee Oberlinger and Edin Karamazov [3] play a programme of pieces by Bach that are arranged for either instrument solo or for the combination of both. Again, we get two of Bach's flute sonatas (BWV 1034 and 1035), but also the allemande from the Partita BWV 1013 for flute solo. The longest item is the last of the programme: the lute suite BWV 997, here in an arrangement for recorder and lute. It works pretty well, and overall the balance is much better than in the two previous recordings. Both players execute their selection of works with much sensitivity and stylistic understanding. Only in the performance of the Concerto in d minor (BWV 974), Bach's arrangement of Alessandro Marcello's oboe concerto, I think Ms Oberlinger goes a little too far in her ornamentation. However, this is a very enjoying disc that will please Bach lovers just as much as recorder and lute aficionados.
That may also be the case with the last disc. Tabea Debus and Alon Sariel [4] open and close their programme with Bach: they start with the lute suite BWV 997 that also figures on the previous disc, but play only three of the four movements. The Partita BWV 1006 for violin solo is performed here in an arrangement for recorder and lute. I don't think I have ever heard this piece with this combination of instruments, but it works surprisingly well. In between are pieces by Silvius Leopold Weiss and Heinrich Franz Ignaz Biber as well as Bach's son Carl Philipp Emanuel. The latter is represented here by his little-known harp sonata - a quite original choice. The pieces by Biber are played well, but especially the passacaglia that closes the collection of Mystery Sonatas is the least-convincing item, probably because the recorder can't quite reproduce the dynamic capabilities of the violin. The two players are excellent, and because of that this disc is interesting and entertaining.
[1] JS Bach: "Music for Recorder & Harpsichord"
Stefano Bagliano, recorder; Andrea Coen, harpsichord
Brilliant Classics 95777 (© 2021) details
[2] JS Bach: "Bach & Flauto & Organo"
Agnès Blanche Marc, recorder; Helene von Rechenberg, organ
Spektral SRL4-20180 (© 2022) details
[3] JS Bach: "Dialoge"
Dorothee Oberlinger, recorder; Edin Karamazov, lute
deutsche harmonia mundi 19439875862 (© 2021) details
[4] "Sounds familiar"
Tabea Debus, recorder; Alon Sariel, lute
gwk records GWK 156 (© 2022) details
Stefano Bagliano and Andrea Coen [1] play three of Bach's flute sonatas, However, one of them, included as BWV 1020 in the Schmieder catalogue, is probably not from JS Bach's pen, but rather written by his son Carl Philipp Emanuel. It is scored for an obbligato harpsichord and flute; in this performance Bagliano plays a soprano recorder which produces a rather penetrating sound, at the cost of the harpsichord. Given that all the parts are treated on equal footing by the composer, that is a problem. The balance between the recorder and the organ is generally better, especially if Bagliano plays an alto recorder. The repertoire is unusual: I can't remember ever having heard some of the 3-part Sinfonias and contrapuncti from Die Kunst der Fuge in a performance by recorder and keyboard. In the Sonata BWV 1032 the recorder is accompanied by the organ in the first two movements, but by the harpsichord in the third, which is rather unsatisfying. The playing leaves nothing to be desired, but all in all I am not really convinced by this recording.
It is no coincidence that the organ is a better match for the recorder than the harpsichord. Both are wind instruments, and the recorder can sound like one of the stops of the organ. The balance is generally better, as the next disc shows. Agnès Blanche Marc and Helene von Rechenberg [2] confine themselves to the oeuvre of Bach and play three of his chamber works for transverse flute(s): BWV 1030, 1031 and 1039. The have extended their programme with the triosonata for organ BWV 527 and the chorale trio Herr Jesu Christ, dich zu uns wend (BWV 655). In these two pieces Ms Marc plays a soprano recorder, and even here it is too dominant, although that may well be due to the recording. In the trio sonata this damages the equal role of all three parts. In the chorale trio it would not be that much of a problem, if the recorder would play the cantus firmus, but here it plays the upper part. The effect is that it overshadows the cantus firmus played at a lower pitch at the organ. I am hesitant to rank this recording among those in the tradition of historical performance practice. The booklet mentions the recorders that are used here, but not whether they are copies of historical instruments. The organ definitely is no historical instrument: It was originally built in 1930 and has been rebuilt in 1983/84; a number of pipes from the old organ were included. Parts of the rebuilt instrument have "a classic 'neo-baroque' disposition", according to the booklet. Those are not the features which makes it suitable for a performance that does justice to the baroque performance practice. Obviously, the organ is in modern pitch and has an equal temperament. That is not what is required in a performance of music by Bach. It results in performances that are a bit dull, even though the playing is alright.
The last two discs have much in common: Bach is in the centre of attention, and the instruments are recorder and lute. This turns out to be a pretty much ideal partnership. Under the title 'Dialogues' Dorothee Oberlinger and Edin Karamazov [3] play a programme of pieces by Bach that are arranged for either instrument solo or for the combination of both. Again, we get two of Bach's flute sonatas (BWV 1034 and 1035), but also the allemande from the Partita BWV 1013 for flute solo. The longest item is the last of the programme: the lute suite BWV 997, here in an arrangement for recorder and lute. It works pretty well, and overall the balance is much better than in the two previous recordings. Both players execute their selection of works with much sensitivity and stylistic understanding. Only in the performance of the Concerto in d minor (BWV 974), Bach's arrangement of Alessandro Marcello's oboe concerto, I think Ms Oberlinger goes a little too far in her ornamentation. However, this is a very enjoying disc that will please Bach lovers just as much as recorder and lute aficionados.
That may also be the case with the last disc. Tabea Debus and Alon Sariel [4] open and close their programme with Bach: they start with the lute suite BWV 997 that also figures on the previous disc, but play only three of the four movements. The Partita BWV 1006 for violin solo is performed here in an arrangement for recorder and lute. I don't think I have ever heard this piece with this combination of instruments, but it works surprisingly well. In between are pieces by Silvius Leopold Weiss and Heinrich Franz Ignaz Biber as well as Bach's son Carl Philipp Emanuel. The latter is represented here by his little-known harp sonata - a quite original choice. The pieces by Biber are played well, but especially the passacaglia that closes the collection of Mystery Sonatas is the least-convincing item, probably because the recorder can't quite reproduce the dynamic capabilities of the violin. The two players are excellent, and because of that this disc is interesting and entertaining.
[1] JS Bach: "Music for Recorder & Harpsichord"
Stefano Bagliano, recorder; Andrea Coen, harpsichord
Brilliant Classics 95777 (© 2021) details
[2] JS Bach: "Bach & Flauto & Organo"
Agnès Blanche Marc, recorder; Helene von Rechenberg, organ
Spektral SRL4-20180 (© 2022) details
[3] JS Bach: "Dialoge"
Dorothee Oberlinger, recorder; Edin Karamazov, lute
deutsche harmonia mundi 19439875862 (© 2021) details
[4] "Sounds familiar"
Tabea Debus, recorder; Alon Sariel, lute
gwk records GWK 156 (© 2022) details
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
